Christine: You’re tuned in to Enterprise Biz Bites. I’m Christine Wong, and I’m joined by,
Freda: Freda Liu.
Christine: And today we are talking about innovation and innovating out of the box for businesses. If you want to get in touch with us today about this topic, we are on WhatsApp at 018 789 8899 and on Twitter @BFMradio. Just something to break up a lot of the anxiety a lot of us are feeling about some uncertain situations happening right now. Anyway, innovating is no longer an option in today’s business environment; it is essential for surviving amongst a sea of competition. So what does it mean for businesses or organisations to innovate, and why is it important for them to do so? Leaders in business environments are focusing on factors that can help them sustain and stay relevant in the current business environment. There is a need to explore new ways to innovate because many problems or issues cannot be solved with old solutions. There needs to be a shift in the way businesses operate, and this should involve innovation.
Freda: Actually, it sort of ties in with the 2 PM announcement when you need to innovate, right? There’s a lot of innovation that needs to happen everywhere. So what is innovation from a business context, though? Innovation refers to the action of introducing a unique and novel idea, product, service, strategy, or business model. Innovation can also mean increasing the usability and durability of the entities mentioned earlier, and this can come in the form of an idea or even a concept that can help give you a competitive edge in the business environment. Many business leaders understand the advantages of innovating the business and how it can cultivate growth in the current business environment. Also important to note: innovation is critical no matter what industry, but there is also a danger in using this as a buzzword. So there needs to be an effort taken to understand the process behind the innovation process.
Christine: Yes. So in this business context, innovation can be broken down into two categories: sustaining and disruptive. Sustaining innovation: this form of innovation can enhance an organisation’s processes and technologies to improve on its product or service to an existing customer base. So this form of innovation is typical of existing businesses that are looking for ways to stay ahead of competitors.
Freda: Okay. The other one is disruptive innovation. Disruptive innovation is becoming more common these days with smaller players taking on larger competitors. Great examples: Uber disrupting the way we move around—well, in this case, Grab here; Netflix disrupting the way we consume media by allowing us to stream our favourite movies or series; Visa disrupting the finance industry by offering credit services. And even as I’m giving these examples, there are already people competing with them in this space.
Christine: Right. There’s already innovation in this space. Absolutely. And also, you might be thinking: why is it important for businesses to innovate, right? Unforeseen challenges are part and parcel of business, so knowing how to innovate can help an organisation stay ahead and grow in the process. And there are some key reasons innovation is crucial for business.
Freda: Well, it allows adaptability. The pandemic disrupted businesses on an unprecedented scale, and many businesses had to innovate to adapt and overcome the challenges brought on by the pandemic.
Christine: It also helps to foster growth. Being stagnant can be extremely detrimental to any business or organisation. Organisation and economic growth through innovation is key to staying competitive.
Freda: Setting business apart from competition. Most industries are populated by multiple competitors who might be offering the same products or services, so being innovative can help a business stand out.
Christine: And of course, you also want to think about reducing cost and increasing revenue, right? One of the biggest positives of innovation is that it could possibly help in this manner, and hopefully you can increase revenue and market share, and that can in turn lead to a reduction in cost.
Freda: So according to Harvard Business School, it can be broken down to four phases called an innovation framework. First of all is to clarify. The first stage of this process is to clarify the problem, which means it would involve research to understand the target audience. The goal should be to identify pain points and frame the issue in a way that allows it to be solved.
Christine: Next is to ideate, right? Ideation processes involve generating ideas to solve the identified problems. Ideation should challenge assumptions and overcome biases to produce innovation.
Freda: The third one is develop. So this stage involves exploring solutions generated during ideation. It should also entail field tests and prototypes to test the solution’s practicality and effectiveness.
Christine: And of course, implementation is the final stage that ties everything together. It involves communicating your developed idea to stakeholders to encourage or grow its adoption to the target market. So, I think we’ve seen a lot—I mean, you mentioned a couple of them already, Freda, but there are a lot of companies and businesses who have innovated over the years. Obviously, one of the things that spurred that forward a lot was, of course, the pandemic. I think it’s been very interesting to see some of the different types and different methods in which businesses have changed with the times and grown stronger as a result.
Freda: Right. And I always feel like maybe sometimes larger companies have more of an issue because they’re so used to doing things a certain way. I think the smaller ones are more nimble; they know they need to pivot fast, right? I was listening to an interview by an athlete, and she was saying, “Always be on a pivot”. That’s the thinking behind every business.
Christine: Yeah. So I think definitely you need to have a lot of agility, regardless of the size of your organisation. You have to keep that in mind, and that should be part of your back end, I think, as well. So, of course, we will not be the only people speaking about this today. We’ll be speaking with Sheila Singam, managing partner at Human Equation, after the break. And of course, if you have any examples of companies or businesses and their innovations, how those have shaped your lifestyle, you can reach us on Twitter @BFMradio and on WhatsApp at 018 789 8899. For now, here’s “Elevation” by U2 on BFM 89.9.
Spot Break: Being first matters. BFM 89.9.
Christine: You’re tuned in to Enterprise Biz Bites. I am Christine Wong. I’m joined by
Freda: Freda Liu
Christine: and today we’re talking about innovation. If you want to get in touch with us about innovation, you can of course reach us on Twitter @BFMradio and on WhatsApp at 018 789 8899. Might be slightly more productive than constantly doomscrolling. Today, on the line with us, we have Sheila Singam, managing partner at Human Equation, who’s going to take us through something called the Three Box Philosophy and how it can be applied to innovation in today’s business environment. Thanks, Sheila, for joining us, as per usual. Well, what is the Three Box Philosophy? Just explain that to us.
Sheila: Yep. It’s a model for innovation proposed by Professor Vijay Govindarajan. He’s a renowned expert on business innovation, and it’s based on the principles of preserving, destroying, and creating. The professor says that innovation needs to be built into the strategy of all organisations if they want to ensure business continuity and relevance. So he puts the different aspects of innovation into three boxes. In his explanation of the philosophy, he starts with Box 3, which is about creating the future. He says organisations need to dedicate resources to developing game-changing innovations that can bring transformation for tomorrow and allow them to pivot their business model. And he says this should be done right now, not just when change hits, which actually may be too late. Having said that, of course, we must innovate for the future while focusing on Box 1, which is the present business we’re in, the money earners, where our income is derived. But even in business continuity for the now, we still have to find new ways to keep it going strong and viable and adding value to our stakeholders. And Box 2 is about forgetting the past, which means that we need to identify the things that are not relevant anymore and to sort of forget them, let go of them, right, while still keeping what works. So keep what is good that will help you to drive your business and sustain it, and get rid of all those old practices and ideologies that are holding you back.
Freda: Okay, Sheila, to expand on the concepts of Box 2, what are some ways we can identify what’s needed or no longer needed from the context of an organisation?
Sheila: Well, we need to examine what are the blockages to our business growth. We need to take note of what’s being said in the media about us, our products, our services, our processes. And we should also study the policies and regulations that we’ve put in place and see which are obsolete and which may be delaying our growth. One example I could think of is hierarchical structures, which are no longer fashionable and should be flattened, right? We should also actually examine the values and beliefs of the employees, particularly the older ones who’ve been in the organisation like forever and who may be entrenched in old ways of doing things and being resistant to change. So one great way of identifying is to speak to stakeholders: our employees, vendors, present customers, potential customers, and anybody, even people out there who kind of know our brand, don’t know of our brand, to find out what are their pain points with regard to the way we do business.
Christine: Right, Sheila, why is it so difficult to get rid of Box 2 even though we all know it is necessary, and what are the steps to do this slowly but surely?
Sheila: Well, in my opinion, one of the biggest things that makes it very, very hard for organisations to get rid of the past is the fear of change. People in the organisation who’ve been following the old ways and it’s been carrying them through sort of decades, they fear that if they get rid of the old ways that have brought them the success of the past years that it will jinx the future. Sometimes it’s also loyalty to those who created the process for success in the past and a reluctance to let them go, lest we are seen to have forgotten them or ungrateful, like the Malay proverb, ‘seperti kacang lupakan kulit’, right? And people may also be threatened that letting go of the things in Box 2 may render them irrelevant. Ultimately, the biggest thing is the fear of change and being entrenched in our comfort zone.
Freda: You see, it sounds just like politics. Now Sheila, how do we encourage Box 3 thinking and make it a culture in an organisation?
Sheila: Box 3 thinking is about innovating for the future. It’s not something that people naturally think of when they are in the daily grind of keeping the present business going and achieving the targets and goals and the bottom line. So ideally, what organisations should do is to set aside resources to practice creativity and innovation—resources like time, people, a space, and a budget. People need to learn how to innovate. It comes naturally to some people, but to some people, they need to be taught, and it can be taught. Design thinking, for example, is a great tool, and I think every organisation should have a design thinking programme that introduces people to creating new ideas, to innovating, and also on how to test the feasible ideas to see if they fly. If they don’t, still reward people for the process because it’s not always necessarily about the end result, right? The journey needs to be rewarded in this instance as much as the destination. Therefore, we should also not slam the failures that take place in the process of innovation, but collectively see them as a learning because I strongly believe there’s no real failure, but there’s only feedback. When things don’t work out, there’s still feedback to be gained on what we can do instead. For me, ideally—something I strongly recommend when I go in to do training and consultancy for organisations—set up an ideation incubator: colourful, fun places where people can go and brainstorm new ideas, solutions to existing problems, solutions to problems that don’t exist yet but might exist in the future, maybe crazy ideas for products and services which we’re not ready for right now, but we might be in 10 years’ time, right? So and also maybe to brainstorm ideas and solutions not necessarily in your own ecosystem, but in the world out there. What do you want to see as a consumer? All right. So because an idea that you have that might not be related to your business, it could be something that you turn into a new business model by partnering with another organisation that has the expertise to execute it. All right. So what we want to do is give people a safe place to play and to come up with innovative new ideas, so basically like a physical Box 3 in your organisation.
Christine: All right, lovely. It is time for us to take a short break for some messages, but we will of course keep Sheila on the line. For now, here is “Abracadabra” by Steve Miller Band here on BFM 89.9.
Spot Break: Broking financial mergers, BFM 89.9.]
Christine: You’re tuned in to Enterprise Biz Bites. I am Christine Wong, and I’m joined by Freda Liu and of course Sheila Singam, the managing partner of Human Equation. Today we’re talking about innovation in business, and of course, if you want to join the conversation today, we are on WhatsApp at 018 789 8899 and on Twitter @BFMradio. Now, before the break, we talked a bit about Box 3 thinking. So Sheila, as we venture into Box 3 thinking, is it also necessary to accept possible failures? If so, how can organisations accept failure as an important part of growth?
Sheila: Well, as I mentioned earlier, failure is part of the process to achieving success. We improve and iterate through failure. Something is not working exactly as we expect it to, we keep improving, right? Organisations are so goal-oriented, so focused on the bottom line, achieving the KPIs for Box 1, which is the present-day business, that they forget that we need to take time to innovate. I mean, if it happens by chance, if innovation happens by chance, then you’re really lucky that way, but sometimes we shouldn’t just leave things to chance; we should put it as part of our plan. So in the process, if we don’t allow for failure, if we penalise—we tell people, “Go and innovate, come up with new ideas, go and test in the market,” but if it fails and then we penalise them if they don’t produce the results that we want, then people will be afraid to even try. You will kill innovation. We must reward the process as well as the results. For those who produce viable, income-generating ideas for your company, give them a portion of the profits, some monetary rewards. For those who don’t succeed, at least recognise them for working on it and give them some sort of incentive anyway, because what they are doing, they are developing the innovation muscle for the organisation.
Freda: Right. Sheila, is it also crucial to factor ESG and sustainability in Box 3 thinking?
Sheila: Oh, definitely. These are what consumers, investors, and business partners are looking for today. After the pandemic, we’ve become even more aware of these factors, right? So if we are going to innovate and create, we should do it with the right values in mind. We definitely must prepare for what the consumers or stakeholders for the future are looking for. So aside from ESG and sustainability, we should actually look at good corporate governance, human rights, and all the other values that are beginning to differentiate companies that operate with integrity versus those that do not. So innovate with integrity.
Christine: Love that. So Sheila, I think final question for you: talk to us about the importance of finding the right balance between the three box concepts. Why is this important, and how can organisations find this balance?
Sheila: Organisations are so focused on keeping Box 1 going, the present business going, and on the bottom-line profits and so on. They do not make time to clean up the past and work on the future. They hardly look at a strategic approach to innovation or allocate resources for it—to training people to do it, to setting aside a budget or a space, or even create room for it in the corporate mindset. And yet, it is the most obvious way to innovate, to create new opportunities for business model innovation, to capture new markets. As we innovate and plan for the future—I mean, if we’re going to put that as part of our strategic plan—we need to also examine and get rid of all the physical and intangible things that might be holding us back, and if necessary divest, change, or let go of them so that they don’t become like the proverbial millstones around the neck. Like, for example, hierarchies, rigid paradigms, stereotyped approaches, companies that are bleeding money—as subsidiary companies, for example—irrelevant departments. They need to go because we need to release the resources and the energy for new things. So yes, it is necessary to attend to all the three boxes in tandem: keep business going as usual, because that’s where your income comes in, while sort of channelling some of those resources to creating and innovating for the future, and at the same time cleaning up and getting rid of the things of the past that are no longer useful or relevant, or might even be holding us back.
Christine: Right. Really, really interesting. Thank you so much, Sheila, for your explanation of the Three Box Philosophy and how it pertains to innovation in business. Freda, any thoughts on that on what she shared?
Freda: No, I think one of the things is like people can’t let go of what I guess is their revenue churner, and that is important, right? Because that keeps the business going. But knowing that you always have to constantly change, I think also she was saying feel safe for people to experiment if it doesn’t work. That’s part of growth, right? You’re going to have some failures as well.
Christine: There is an element of not being complacent as well, and not simply blindly assuming that the same thing will work over time. You have to keep reinventing and taking another look at your processes and updating them with time, right? You can’t… Yeah, you can’t keep doing the same thing forever. Anyways, that brings us to the end of today’s show. Thanks again to Sheila for speaking to us. Do not go anywhere though; after the 1 PM news bulletin is of course the Breakfast Grille replay. As the chaos of the night of GE15 simmers down—kind of—the Breakfast Grille tried to unpack the results of election night and what this means for the future of the country with a special Breakfast Grille discussion where political expert Ibrahim Sufyan dissected and analysed the trends that came out. So tune in to have a better understanding of why the vote went the way it did and what the coming weeks will look like for Malaysia. This is Enterprise Biz Bites. On behalf of myself, Christine Wong, and Freda Liu, here is “Little Lies” by Fleetwood Mac on BFM 89.9.
Closing Spot Break: You have been listening to a podcast from BFM 89.9, the business station. For more stories of the same kind, download the BFM app.